1 4

Your One-Stop-Shop for All of Your Vintage Toys & Collectibles!

Favorite Collections

View all

Three Ways to Find Us

  • In Store

    We have finally found a new home where we can stand on our own and have more space to expand our inventory :)

    Visit us at 18 Quimby Lane Bernardsville, NJ!!

  • Shop Online

    Browse our newly revamped online shopping experience. New products are constantly added and even more are in stock at our new location!

    Shop Now

  • Mobile Toy Store

    Find us at Toy Cons, 80's Events, and many other themed events with vintage toys as we go on the road with our 24 foot enclosed retail store on wheels! Oh, and almost forgot...it accompanies a replica of the Time Machine from Back to the Future!

    Events

Introducing the CollectiBag

Each bag is a mystery-packed bundle of retro treasures and toy surprises hand-picked from our vault of vintage favorites and pop-culture classics.

Shop CollectiBags

"Stumbled upon this gem during our little Sunday family stroll and we are so happy we did! What a cool store w tons of nostalgia. Very organized, fair pricing and the owner was super cool. We got our son 2 retro cars that he is so happy with and would definitely come back again!"

Isidro R

"AMAZING selection. One of the best around. Go. Now."

M.R.

"Stopped in today with my son and buddy and was impressed with the selection. We all walked out very happy. Great prices and friendly owners. We will definitely come back soon. Also thanks for recommending the Mexican restaurant across the street. Great food to cap off a great day!"

David C.

"Very friendly , answered all my questions went above and beyond will definitely come back thanks again"

Ricky M

1 4

A Bit About TMC

It all started with Tim—an ’80s kid who never stopped collecting the toys he loved growing up.

Over the years, he shared that passion with his two boys, celebrating creativity, imagination, and classic play. What began as an Instagram page in 2021 soon grew into something bigger, leading to the launch of a pop-up vintage toy store in 2023 alongside fellow collectors.

Today, That’s My Collectible is home to a dedicated storefront packed with iconic toys from the ’70s through the ’90s, plus modern retro favorites. Discover how a childhood passion turned into an adventure nearly forty years in the making.

Got a Collection to Sell?

We're interested!  Whether it's vintage action figures, classic cars, or rare finds, contact us to discuss your collection.

Contact Us

Follow us on Instagram @thatsmycollectible

Our Pals & Partners