About Us

That’s My Collectible was founded by Tim Manning, a once 80’s kid that was lucky enough to experience some of the coolest toys ever created! Eventually being forced to get older by father time, he had kept his childhood toys and started collecting vintage toys in his mid 20's as he shared these memories with his daughter who also loved them. As time passed and collecting stopped again for a while, he then started again with his two sons but this time with an entirely new purpose. 

Encouraging his children’s creative development and sparking imagination through a digital time, he shared all of his classic vintage toys with them as if it was still 1985. This taught them to take care of and the appreciation of vintage toys as well learn as that some can be sold to other people who also love them, which can help to achieve getting the final figures to complete their collection. 

Starting an Instagram page is 2021 and meeting so many wonderful collectors along the way, That's My Collectible was born.

In 2023 Tim Joined forces with a fellow toy collector, now friend, Adam Sutherland who has been a lifelong fan and collector of mainly vintage Star Wars. Together they opened the very first in-person That's My Collectible Pop-Up Vintage Toy Store in Bernardsville, NJ late 2023!

In March 2024, they built and launched their very first Mobile Vintage Toy Store which was an immediate success.  Partnering with Doc's Time Machines, the mobile store also accompanies a full-sized drivable Delorean Time Machine Replica from the movie Back to the Future.

Now, late 2024, they have found a more permanent home in the same town as their pop-up which will be opening in November.

Keep an eye on Facebook & Instagram to see what is coming next!

Skeletor crashed Spydor in the path of the Horde. They are ticked. So Beast Man used his ability to speak to animals and called some cats to attack.

This scene was originally set up by the kids...and then the cats took over and made for a better pic LOL