About TMC
That’s My Collectible was founded by Tim Manning—an ’80s kid who never stopped loving the toys that defined his childhood.
What began as a personal collection grew into a passion for sharing vintage toys with his children, encouraging creativity, imagination, and hands-on play in a digital world. In 2021, Tim began sharing that journey on Instagram, connecting with fellow collectors and building a community around nostalgia and classic toys.
That passion moved offline in late 2023 with the opening of the first That’s My Collectible Pop-Up Vintage Toy Store in Bernardsville, New Jersey. In 2024, the brand expanded with a Mobile Vintage Toy Store, bringing curated vintage toys to events throughout the region. Through a partnership with Doc’s Time Machines, the mobile experience also features a full-size, drivable DeLorean Time Machine replica from Back to the Future.
Today, That’s My Collectible has a permanent home in Bernardsville, NJ—offering a carefully curated selection of iconic toys from the 1970s through the 1990s, alongside modern retro favorites.
At its core, That’s My Collectible is about nostalgia, community, and rediscovering the toys that made growing up unforgettable.
Why Collectors Love Us
- Authentic vintage toys, carefully sourced
- Knowledgeable staff who are collectors themselves
- In-store, mobile, and event-based experiences
- A welcoming space for kids, parents, and lifelong fans
Creative Play. No Video Games, No Phones, Just Old School Imagination.
Skeletor crashed Spydor in the path of the Horde. They are ticked. So Beast Man used his ability to speak to animals and called some cats to attack.
This scene was originally set up by the kids...and then the cats took over and made for a better pic LOL
